Do Illegal Immigrants Pay Taxes? Yes, But Nowhere Near Enough
It's not half of what they cost. It's not even half. The fullest count found about 17 cents in taxes for every dollar spent, and the bill keeps coming, child after child, generation after generation.
Do illegal immigrants pay taxes? Yes, some. But nowhere near enough to cover what they cost, and anyone who tells you "they pay taxes, so they belong here" is selling you a bill of goods. I have been collecting the studies on this for about a year and a half because the claim never goes away. Here is the bottom line: when you add up the schools, the hospitals, the benefits for their children, the jobs and the wages lost, the taxes they pay do not come close. This page is my reference. Use it.

The Numbers: 17 Cents on the Dollar
The most complete count of both sides of the ledger is the Federation for American Immigration Reform's 2023 report. In one year:
- $182.1 billion spent by federal, state and local governments on illegal immigrants and their U.S.-born children.
- $31.4 billion paid back in taxes, after the tax credits they collected.
- $150.7 billion left for everyone else. That is about $956 out of every taxpayer's pocket, every year.
Their taxes covered about 17 percent of what they cost. Not half. Not even a fifth. FAIR's 2017 report found the same gap on smaller numbers: $134.9 billion spent, $19 billion paid, $115.9 billion left over.
What Taxes They Actually Pay
Here is everything the "they pay taxes" crowd is pointing at:
- Sales tax on what they buy.
- Property tax, indirectly, through rent.
- Payroll and income tax, but only when they work on the books. Some file with a taxpayer ID number (ITIN). Others work under a Social Security number that belongs to someone else, which is fraud.
The left-leaning Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP) puts it at $96.7 billion for 2022. That is the number you see on social media. It counts every dollar that goes in and not one dollar that goes out.
The Claim You Will Hear
Robert Reich, the former Labor Secretary, pushes this one constantly:
That is ITEP's number, rounded up. Notice what is missing: the cost. A business that only reported its sales and never its expenses would be committing fraud. Reich does it in public and calls it an argument.
Where the Money Goes
Illegal immigrants are barred from most federal welfare by the 1996 welfare reform law: no food stamps, no regular Medicaid, no SSI, no public housing for themselves. So how does the bill hit $182 billion? Their children, their hospital visits, their schooling, and the sanctuary cities and states that house and feed them on the taxpayer's dime.
- Schools. Public schools spent $17,619 per student in 2024, according to the Census Bureau. FAIR puts the K-12 cost of illegal immigration at $75.7 billion a year, the biggest single item, and almost all of it is paid by your state and your local property taxes.
- Anchor babies. A child born here to illegal immigrant parents is a citizen, and qualifies for Medicaid, food stamps and every other benefit on the same terms as any other American child. The parents broke the law to get here, and the taxpayer picks up the tab for the family anyway.
- Emergency rooms. Federal law (EMTALA) requires every hospital emergency room to treat anyone who walks in, regardless of status or ability to pay. Whatever emergency Medicaid does not cover gets eaten by the hospital, and hospitals pass it on to everyone else through higher bills and higher insurance premiums.
Denver Health, the city's public hospital, is one example. More than 8,000 migrants made about 20,000 visits in roughly a year. Its CEO put their care at about $10 million in 2023, on top of $140 million the hospital was already carrying in unpaid care. One hospital, one city, one year.
Hotels, Food and Debit Cards: New York and California
No food stamps, no Medicaid, no Social Security, so the cities and states that call themselves sanctuaries stepped in with your money instead:
- New York City spent about $9.46 billion on migrants from July 2022 through May 2026, according to the City Council. More than 237,000 people passed through the city's care.
- About $134,000 a year per family. The city's cost to shelter and feed one migrant household was $367 a night as of June 2026, and $383 a night in 2023. Food alone cost the city $647 million.
- The Roosevelt Hotel. The city signed a three-year, $220 million deal for all 1,025 rooms of the landmark Manhattan hotel, owned by Pakistan International Airlines, and used it as its migrant intake center from May 2023 to June 2025. More than 173,000 people registered there.
- Prepaid debit cards. New York handed a $53 million no-bid contract to a company to load debit cards for migrant families, about $350 a week for a family of four, before ending the program in January 2025.
- California spends about $8.5 billion a year from its general fund to give full Medi-Cal coverage to undocumented immigrants. It ran $2.7 billion over budget, the state had to borrow to cover it, and it froze new enrollment for undocumented adults starting in 2026.
And when someone tells you, "That's state and city money, not federal," don't buy it. About one of every three dollars states spend comes from Washington, 33.5 percent in 2025, according to the National Association of State Budget Officers. The federal government also sent money straight to migrant shelters: $800 million through FEMA in 2023 and $650 million more in 2024. In February 2025, FEMA wired New York City another $80.5 million for migrant shelters before the money was pulled back. Federal, state or city, it is the same taxpayer, and it is the same wallet.
The Bill Does Not Stop at One Generation
This is the part the other side never puts in its math. The cost of illegal immigration is not a one-time bill. It repeats.
- Thirteen years of public school at $17,619 a year is about $229,000 per child at today's spending, before a single special education, language or free lunch program.
- Every one of those anchor babies is a citizen whose own children will be educated at public expense too, and their children after them. Every new illegal arrival restarts that cycle.
- The Center for Immigration Studies estimated the average lifetime net cost of each illegal border crosser at about $74,722 (figured in present value), using the National Academies' own education figures. That is one person, not a family, and not their descendants.
In my opinion, nobody can put an honest number on the total, because it compounds. Every study you will see gives you one year, or one lifetime. None of them follows the bill through the children and grandchildren, and that is exactly where it keeps growing.
What the National Academies Found
The biggest neutral study, the National Academies of Sciences 2016 report The Economic and Fiscal Consequences of Immigration, found that first-generation immigrants and their dependents "tend to be more costly to state and local governments," mainly because of the cost of educating their children. It found the least-educated immigrants cost the most. That is exactly the group most illegal immigrants fall into.
The Tax Credits: Money Going Back Out
"They pay income tax" also ignores the refunds. Until 2025, a parent filing with an ITIN could claim the refundable Child Tax Credit for a U.S.-born child. FAIR counts $8.4 billion a year in tax credits flowing back out to illegal immigrant households. The One Big Beautiful Bill finally closed most of that: starting with the 2025 tax year, the person claiming the credit needs a Social Security number valid for work.
The Jobs They Take and the Wages They Cut
"They take jobs nobody wants" is not true. They take jobs Americans were doing for more money. Harvard economist George Borjas found that a 10 percent increase in workers with the same skills lowers their wages by 3 to 4 percent. Construction, roofing, landscaping, cleaning, restaurants: these are the jobs that hit, held by the people trying to work their way into the middle class.
And it hits every small business that plays by the rules. If you carry workers' comp, pay payroll taxes and hold your licenses, you are bidding against someone paying cash off the books. Their price is lower because their costs got passed to the hospital, the school district and you.
Their Comebacks, and Why They Fail
- "ITEP says $96.7 billion in taxes." It measures taxes only. Zero costs. Half a ledger.
- "The CBO says it cuts the deficit." The Congressional Budget Office projected about $0.9 trillion in lower federal deficits over ten years. It left out discretionary spending, and the CBO itself said state and local costs would likely rise more than state and local revenue. That is where the schools and emergency rooms are.
- "Their kids grow up to be taxpayers." The National Academies did find that some children of immigrants become strong earners. That is a bet on twenty years from now, paid for with your property taxes today, and it assumes those children will not cost anything for their own children. It does not cover the parents' bill either way.
- "Cato says the cost is much lower." Cato's Alex Nowrasteh put it at $3.3 billion to $15.6 billion a year by counting less. Leave out enough costs and anything looks cheap.
The Bottom Line in One Minute
- Yes, they pay some taxes: sales tax, rent, and payroll tax when they work on the books.
- The fullest count found $182 billion in costs against $31 billion in taxes. About 17 cents on the dollar.
- The biggest costs are schools, benefits for anchor babies, and emergency rooms, paid mostly by your state and your property taxes.
- The bill repeats with every child and every generation, and no study counts all of it.
- "Jobs nobody wants" means lower wages for the Americans already doing them.
- "They pay taxes" is true. "So they pay their way" is not.
- FAIR: The Fiscal Burden of Illegal Immigration on United States Taxpayers 2023
- FAIR: 2017 study, illegal immigration costs $116 billion annually
- National Academies of Sciences: The Economic and Fiscal Consequences of Immigration (2016)
- Center for Immigration Studies: The Cost of a Border Wall vs. the Cost of Illegal Immigration (2017)
- ITEP: Tax Payments by Undocumented Immigrants (2024)
- CBO: Effects of the Immigration Surge on the Federal Budget and the Economy (2024)
- HHS: Summary of Immigrant Eligibility Restrictions Under Current Law
- Census Bureau: Public school spending per pupil, fiscal 2024
- CMS: Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA)
- Denver Health: 2025 Implementation Plan (uncompensated care)
- New York City Council: Asylum Seekers Terms and Conditions Report (May 2026)
- NYC Independent Budget Office: Asylum seeker cost projections (December 2023)
- NYC Mayor's Office: Closure of the Roosevelt Hotel arrival center (July 2025)
- The Real Deal: City rents Roosevelt Hotel from Pakistan for $220M
- Scripps News: NYC to roll out $53 million prepaid card program for migrant families
- amNY: NYC to end debit card program for migrant families
- NYC Comptroller: Fiscal impacts of asylum seeker services (federal funds to NYC)
- CalMatters: Medi-Cal budget shortfall (March 2025)
- CalMatters: Newsom freezes Medi-Cal enrollment for undocumented adults
- Congressional Research Service: FEMA Shelter and Services Program
- NY1: Judge rejects NYC's request for return of $80 million FEMA money
- NASBO: 2025 State Expenditure Report (federal share of state spending)
- IRS: 2025 Form 1040 instructions (Child Tax Credit SSN rule)
- George Borjas: The Labor Demand Curve Is Downward Sloping (NBER / Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2003)
- @RBReich on X, September 21, 2024